Piano Man
Mr. Gao runs a business specializing in secondhand pianos and piano moving. He acquires pianos from people who no longer need them and resells them to new customers. Sometimes, a customer who initially hires him to move a piano ends up purchasing another one from him. For Gao, reselling pianos is often more profitable than moving them.
Given the cost of fuel and the daily wages of his workers, Gao usually schedules several piano moves on the same day. During transportation, the pianos are secured inside the truck with heavy-duty straps. Upon arrival, they are lowered to the ground using a hydraulic liftgate before being moved into the customer's home.
The procedure is much the same each time, yet the movers never know exactly what awaits them inside the next customer's home. Tiled floors are relatively easy to navigate, while wooden floors require additional protection. Sometimes, Gao lays protective carpeting all the way from the entrance of a house to its basement. A few seemingly ordinary steps can become the most difficult part of the entire job. Several grown men find themselves wrestling with gravity, lifting a heavy piano one step at a time.
A piano move typically costs around $300, excluding tips, while one of Gao's assistants earns approximately $100 a day. Even minor damage sustained during a move can lead to customer complaints and deductions from the moving fee. After paying for labor, fuel, and vehicle expenses, Gao sometimes loses money if he fails to sell a piano that day.
During the project, I would often receive a phone call from Gao early in the morning and had to be ready to leave at short notice. I accompanied him on five or six piano moves, traveling in his truck from one customer's home to another. Eventually, as his business required more hands, Gao became increasingly reluctant to take me along.
The seat I occupied in his truck was a seat that could have been given to another worker.
At the Edge of the Protest
In June 2025, demonstrations against U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement took place over several consecutive days in Lower Manhattan. Protesters opposed the government's intensified immigration enforcement, detention, and deportation policies. According to local news reports, demonstrators on June 11 marched from Foley Square along Broadway, with protests extending to the areas surrounding 26 Federal Plaza and the Manhattan Detention Center.
In the square, several demonstrators stood on a makeshift platform, waving flags and shouting. Police officers surrounded the gathering, but rather than facing the demonstrators, they faced outward toward passing pedestrians. Some remained expressionless, while others spoke about matters unrelated to the protest, occasionally smiling. During the period I observed, the work of the police and the activities of the demonstrators appeared to coexist without direct confrontation.
Another group of police officers stood around a large black granite sculpture titled Triumph of the Human Spirit. Created by artist Lorenzo Pace and dedicated in 2000, the monument commemorates the history of African Americans in New York. The officers and demonstrators faced one another from a distance. Some demonstrators asked why the officers were guarding the sculpture, but received no response.
Nearby, a pedestrian carrying a dog on their shoulders walked past the large formation of police officers.
A demonstrator wearing an American flag had just been driven out of the group by other protesters. They objected to his wearing the American flag and wanted him to wear a Palestinian flag instead. He attempted to explain that his flag was being displayed upside down, but his explanation was not accepted.
Visibly discouraged, he sat down on a nearby bench with a friend. A short while later, a police officer passed in front of them, walking toward the gathering.
They glanced at one another without exchanging a word.
After the Scream
Inside a record shop on Van Brunt Street in Brooklyn, musicians and audience members gathered for an anti-fascist concert commemorating the 36th anniversary of the 1989 Tiananmen crackdown. The event was titled Tiananmen Massacre Anniversary / FUCK FASCISM Concert.
Among the performers was Rose Tang, a participant and organizer in the 1989 student movement in Beijing. After leaving China, she worked as a journalist and later became an experimental musician. More than three decades later, she continues to engage with the history of that period through her artistic practice and activism.
Her music was filled with dissonance, chaotic rhythms, and screams that bordered on hysteria. Conventional notions of melody, order, and harmony seemed deliberately dismantled. This was not a concert centered on the enjoyment of melody in the conventional sense. Yet the audience responded to her performance with remarkable enthusiasm. There was an extraordinary intensity in both her voice and her physical presence.
What I sensed in the room was not merely an appreciation of the music, but also a respect for someone who had lived through that history. People had gathered to give voice to their experiences and concerns, and to listen to one another. Music became a means of remembering the past and expressing political concerns in the present.
Photographer’s Note
The performance also led me to question the nature of remembrance and resistance.
What exactly are we raising our voices against? An event that took place more than three decades ago? A political system that continues to exist today? Or a relationship with power that may recur in different societies? What is the relationship between those who exercise political power today and those who exercised it at the time?
When resistance becomes a recurring collective activity, what effect does it have on the world outside that gathering? Are we preserving historical memory and attempting to change the present, or are we also finding emotional release and a sense of belonging through these activities?
If one day the object of our opposition no longer exists, what will become of these gatherings? What should we do after the scream?
If we were to do nothing, would the world necessarily become a worse place? Or would we simply feel worse about ourselves for having done nothing?
I left the concert carrying these unanswered questions.
A House Returned
David grew up in this house. It originally belonged to his maternal grandfather, Eddie Joe, who lived there until his death. Both of his daughters, Amy and Abby, had been involved in caring for him.
After Eddie Joe died, the house passed to Abby, the older sister. The inheritance became the source of a longstanding family dispute. According to the family history as it was related to me, Amy believed that she had undertaken a greater share of the responsibility for caring for her father and could not understand why the property had been left to her sister.
The two sisters had a serious argument, and their relationship broke down. Abby subsequently refused to allow Amy to return to live in the house.
More than a decade later, through a financial transaction involving a farm, David acquired ownership of the property. In a sense, the house in which he had spent his childhood had finally returned to him and his mother.
By then, however, the house had been unoccupied for nearly thirteen years. The building had deteriorated severely. Parts of the second floor had begun to sag, and some building materials had fallen through to the floor below. The structure was in a precarious condition.
Although David had regained ownership of the house, he was unsure what to do with it, or whether it would ever be possible for his mother to live there again.
Photographer’s Note
Over thirteen years, the house had gradually fallen into disrepair, while the family relationships connected to it had remained fractured.
What David now faced was not simply an aging house in need of restoration, but unresolved conflicts inherited from an older generation and a family history that could no longer easily be restored.
The house had returned. The people who once lived in it, their relationships, and the house as it once was might not.
The Silent Trade
By seven or eight in the morning, trading is already underway in an antique market in Lhasa. It continues until around one in the afternoon. Beads, jewelry, dzi beads, Buddhist statues, ritual objects, and various vessels circulate through the market, including items from Tibet, Nepal, and other neighboring regions.
People gather to discuss the materials, craftsmanship, and condition of these objects. Such conversations are as much a form of everyday social interaction as an exercise in evaluating merchandise. Actual negotiations, however, often take place in silence.
A buyer and a seller clasp hands, concealing them beneath the sleeves of their robes. Through a system of gestures understood by both parties, they negotiate the price without speaking. Once an agreement has been reached, they may arrange another time and place to complete the exchange. Transactions do not always involve money; barter remains part of the trading culture.
Meanwhile, other vendors call out loudly, offering jewelry and souvenirs to tourists. The ability to identify an object's materials, craftsmanship, age, and condition is an important form of knowledge in this market. Without it, a buyer may struggle to determine what an object is worth.
Some vendors and content creators use the antique market as a backdrop for livestreams, attracting online audiences, displaying merchandise, and taking orders from distant customers. Commercial practices from different eras coexist within the same marketplace.
Four months later, in Times Square, New York, I encountered a man dressed in Buddhist monastic robes offering prayer beads for sale.
He wandered through the crowds carrying his beads. During the two or three hours I observed him, I did not witness a single completed sale. When I raised my camera, he concealed the beads.
I did not know his religious identity or where his merchandise had come from.
In two geographically distant cities, similar objects appeared within very different commercial and cultural environments. In Lhasa, traditional transactions rely on shared knowledge, customs, and social relationships. In Times Square, the man found himself among a constantly shifting crowd of strangers.
Beneath Marilyn's Skirt
An eight-meter-tall sculpture of Marilyn Monroe stood inside the Central Avenue Shopping Mall in Dalian, a city in northeastern China. Installed in 2016, the sculpture recreated the iconic scene from the 1955 film The Seven Year Itch, in which Monroe's white dress is lifted by a gust of air.
In 1953, Monroe appeared on the cover of the inaugural issue of Playboy. Over the following decades, she became one of the most recognizable symbols of female sexuality in global popular culture.
Directly beneath her enormous skirt, the Chinese eyewear brand HORIEN was holding a promotional event. Its advertising featured Teens in Times, a seven-member Chinese boy band formed in 2019.
Teens in Times is part of China's contemporary idol industry, which fosters sustained emotional relationships between young performers and their fans by publicly documenting their growth, everyday lives, and interactions with one another. Its female audience spans different age groups, and fans develop various forms of emotional attachment, ranging from romantic fantasy and protective affection to an interest in the performers' professional development.
Intersecting with this industry are the cultures of danmei, or Boys' Love, and fan-created romantic pairings. Some fans imagine emotional or romantic relationships between male idols and explore these relationships through fiction, images, and videos. These practices also reflect the role of women as viewers, consumers, and reinterpreters of commercially produced male imagery.
Within a shopping mall in northeastern China, two icons of popular culture, separated by several decades, occupied the same commercial space.
On one side was an emblem of female sexuality produced by twentieth-century Hollywood. On the other was an image of youthful masculinity produced by China's contemporary idol industry.
Two eras of aesthetics, desire, and commercial consumption met unexpectedly beneath Marilyn's enormous white skirt.